People who own a flat on a long lease usually pay a service charge for shared costs such as repairs and insurance. A bill before Parliament would let building owners put the cost of registering certain blocks of flats in England on that bill, even if the lease says nothing about it. A Commons committee voted on 19 November to keep the provision in the bill.

Labour MP Hilary Benn had asked whether flat owners can be charged for checking for a building safety problem. In a written reply on 19 November, housing department minister Florence Eshalomi said leaseholders who qualify for protection under the Building Safety Act 2022 cannot be charged for certain professional assessments linked to a defect that the Act covers. We compared that rule with the new bill to find out which costs could reach the same flat owner.

When an EWS1 form can be covered

A lender can ask for an EWS1 form when someone buys or remortgages a flat. It reports what a professional has found about the fire risk posed by the building’s outside walls. A fire risk appraisal of external walls is a separate assessment that helps a building owner decide what safety work is needed.

Eshalomi said the protection covers the cost of either assessment when it relates to a defect covered by the Act and the lease qualifies. The law bars a service charge under such a lease for professional services connected with who is or might be liable for the defect.

Those protections generally apply in buildings in England that are at least 11 metres high or have at least five storeys, subject to other conditions. Whether a lease qualifies usually turns on who held it on 14 February 2022. A long lease granted before then can qualify if the flat was that person’s main home or they owned no more than three homes in the UK, including that flat. That protection can carry over when someone buys the flat later.

What could go on the service charge bill

The government’s Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill would create a register of occupied blocks classed as medium-rise in England. The bill sets the lower threshold at 11 metres or five storeys, and the block has to be under both 18 metres and seven storeys. The aim is to give regulators better information about buildings where they may need to act on safety risks. The proposal would let building owners recover costs connected with registration and providing the required information. These can include the registration fee, management costs and professional fees.

The provision covers leases originally granted for at least seven years that require a service charge. It excludes the social housing tenancies defined in the bill. Where a lease splits different costs in different ways, the bill says the new costs that it alone makes chargeable would be divided the same way as the building’s insurance bill.

Eshalomi told the committee that government modelling puts the average initial cost at £28 per resident. That is an estimate across buildings, and the bill sets no £28 cap. The department is looking at setting benchmarks for charges. We previously reported when flat owners will get clearer service charge bills and accounts under separate reforms.

The registration charge is still a proposal. The same flat owner could keep the protection against paying for a professional assessment linked to a covered defect and still face a share of the cost of putting the building on the register.